Cedar Notes

Reading methods and practical tool notes.

Reading in layers

A working note on difficult texts.

A dense essay is easier when you stop trying to understand every sentence on the first pass. Read it in layers, and let each layer answer a smaller question.

First pass: the shape

Skim headings, the opening and closing paragraphs, and any section that announces a claim. When you finish, you should be able to say what kind of text this is and where the author is going. You do not need the details yet.

Second pass: the argument

Read straight through, marking the main claims and the evidence offered for each one. Write a five-line summary in your own words. If you cannot do that, you have found the unclear part; go back only there.

Third pass: the knots

Return to the sentences you marked. Look up only the terms that block the argument. Copy one or two quotations, then close the book and write what you still disagree with or do not understand. That last sentence is often the most useful note.